Anarchists For Expert Government
Today was my 1 afternoon of beingness a tourist inwards New York. After the furnish trip to the Natural History Museum I went downtown to run across the "Occupy Wall Street" protestation inwards Liberty Square. I had no clue well-nigh their agenda in addition to the full general description was that they did non represent anything. If they stood for something similar bringing dorsum Glass Steagell maybe nosotros would empathize it in addition to perhaps they would accomplish something - but it seemed far more unfocused than that.
My destination was to function out what they wanted in addition to for that I was going to role a elementary question tool. I was going to inquire them.
On the periphery I institute gold-bugs in addition to anti-fed activists - non genuinely business office of the primary group. They were a lonely looking lot. This photograph of one, standing alone, describes them accurately:
Somewhere betwixt the lone-ranger gold-bugs in addition to the protestation were the police. They were numerous in addition to 1 of their horses startled in addition to scared me. One protester was walking past times amongst a placard protesting the extent of constabulary presence in addition to the seeming terms of that.
I thought he had a point. To an Australian the constabulary seemed far to a greater extent than scary than the protesters though when I asked a protester well-nigh them he thought the constabulary were "well behaved".
The outset detailed conversation I had was amongst a middle-aged guy who was at that topographic point "largely to practice his outset amendment rights" in addition to the "rights embedded inwards the constitution". He did non genuinely know what he was proverb except that he had the correct to state it in addition to that it somehow involved adept government. He did non similar the libertarians (who he thought were rather silly) but he form of liked the anarchy of the whole scene. And he gave me the quote of the day. The protesters were "anarchists for adept government".
Anarchists for adept authorities sounded light-headed but it was accurate. Whilst at that topographic point were people carrying placards that said "fight for socialism" that was non why whatever of the people I asked said they were there. They were at that topographic point because the organisation was broken. They thought that income distribution was screwy inwards America in addition to whilst they thought the Wall Street bailouts mightiness remove maintain been necessary they institute large bonuses inwards bailed out banks deeply offensive. And I can't state I blame them.
They almost universally thought that authorities was owned past times "corporations" in addition to uber-rich individuals who remove maintain purchased the politicians. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 middle aged adult woman was carrying a placard wanting "no to a greater extent than congressional whores". Almost universally they thought the organisation did non function for them but it did function for unopen to shadowy elite.
But if you lot asked them what to create well-nigh it they did non know. Some had specific ideas (one argued that the Citizens United Judgement should endure overturned). Most nonetheless had no specific agenda at all - simply a full general feeling of malaise well-nigh the economy.
Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 pretty immature dark adult woman I spoke to was well-nigh the most lucid mortal I found. She thought the American dream had been narrowed to a really little elite in addition to that shape distinction was rampant. She was at the protestation because she thought that Wall Street was the most obvious bastion of elitism inwards America.
I asked her what she wanted to create inwards life in addition to she said she wanted to function inwards the fashion manufacture inwards New York. I looked at her puzzled in addition to she sheepishly admitted that was unopen to other bastion of elitism. Then she told me she wanted to laid out her ain company. I wished her luck. She was charming inwards her hypocrisy.
This placard best summarized the crowd:
Our economic scheme could endure "more fair" is a reasonable tilt of want or fifty-fifty fact - but it contains no prescription at all. The U.S.A. has had times of high income inequality (the Guilded Age, now) in addition to times of lower income inequality. And I create non want to state it was the New Deal or anything else that caused changing income distribution. Income distribution inwards Commonwealth of Australia was flattest at the halt of a really extended catamenia (23 years) of Conservative government. The economic scheme could be to a greater extent than fair. Then 1 time to a greater extent than it could endure less fair.
Somehow nosotros remove maintain developed a winner-takes-a-great-deal economy. I regret non bespeak these people if they begrudged Steve Jobs dying amongst seven billion dollars personal wealth. I somehow doubtfulness it. iPhones were ubiquitous in addition to they clearly believe that Jobs created something that they wanted.
But they would remove maintain universally thought it unreasonable that Wall Street CEOs were hence rich when their banks were bailed out.
In other words they had a thought that the economic scheme could endure to a greater extent than fair in addition to that their Definition of fairness genuinely accords amongst a lot of other Americans. Plenty of people would concur amongst them.
The Tea Party protesters inwards America are also animated past times a feeling that the organisation could endure to a greater extent than fair - equally are the people who protested the Federal Reserve bank. For that affair the (very small) minority at this protestation wanting "socialism" in all probability experience that agency too. The feeling is unifying. The prescriptions equally to what to create well-nigh it are not.
And the puzzling business office of this protestation was that at that topographic point was no consistent prescription in addition to nobody arguing for 1 - hence they were unified past times their mutual feeling in addition to non divided past times their hostility to each other's prescriptions.
In other words similar most Americans they create non remove maintain a practical clue on how to larn the sort of economic scheme they want in addition to the sort of politics they want. And hence they had no agenda at all.
But most Americans don't become to protests. These people become to this strangely unfocused protest. This homo - clearly middle-class in addition to ameliorate dressed said it quite well. He was at this protestation in addition to he simply wanted to tell you lot that. He had no agenda.
I institute the lack of an agenda puzzling equally did 1 life-time protester I talked to (someone who thought that growth-led capitalism would eventually neglect because of environmental problems). He thought it was the most anarchic protestation he had always been to (no leader, no agenda). But hence he thought the nutrient was ameliorate than at whatever protestation he had been to. I repeated the anarchists for adept authorities describe of piece of job to him in addition to he agreed. Then he said, pointing at dinner simply beingness wheeled out, that the nutrient was great. It was also he said anarchists amongst adept government.
John
My destination was to function out what they wanted in addition to for that I was going to role a elementary question tool. I was going to inquire them.
On the periphery I institute gold-bugs in addition to anti-fed activists - non genuinely business office of the primary group. They were a lonely looking lot. This photograph of one, standing alone, describes them accurately:
Somewhere betwixt the lone-ranger gold-bugs in addition to the protestation were the police. They were numerous in addition to 1 of their horses startled in addition to scared me. One protester was walking past times amongst a placard protesting the extent of constabulary presence in addition to the seeming terms of that.
I thought he had a point. To an Australian the constabulary seemed far to a greater extent than scary than the protesters though when I asked a protester well-nigh them he thought the constabulary were "well behaved".
The outset detailed conversation I had was amongst a middle-aged guy who was at that topographic point "largely to practice his outset amendment rights" in addition to the "rights embedded inwards the constitution". He did non genuinely know what he was proverb except that he had the correct to state it in addition to that it somehow involved adept government. He did non similar the libertarians (who he thought were rather silly) but he form of liked the anarchy of the whole scene. And he gave me the quote of the day. The protesters were "anarchists for adept government".
Anarchists for adept authorities sounded light-headed but it was accurate. Whilst at that topographic point were people carrying placards that said "fight for socialism" that was non why whatever of the people I asked said they were there. They were at that topographic point because the organisation was broken. They thought that income distribution was screwy inwards America in addition to whilst they thought the Wall Street bailouts mightiness remove maintain been necessary they institute large bonuses inwards bailed out banks deeply offensive. And I can't state I blame them.
They almost universally thought that authorities was owned past times "corporations" in addition to uber-rich individuals who remove maintain purchased the politicians. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 middle aged adult woman was carrying a placard wanting "no to a greater extent than congressional whores". Almost universally they thought the organisation did non function for them but it did function for unopen to shadowy elite.
But if you lot asked them what to create well-nigh it they did non know. Some had specific ideas (one argued that the Citizens United Judgement should endure overturned). Most nonetheless had no specific agenda at all - simply a full general feeling of malaise well-nigh the economy.
Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 pretty immature dark adult woman I spoke to was well-nigh the most lucid mortal I found. She thought the American dream had been narrowed to a really little elite in addition to that shape distinction was rampant. She was at the protestation because she thought that Wall Street was the most obvious bastion of elitism inwards America.
I asked her what she wanted to create inwards life in addition to she said she wanted to function inwards the fashion manufacture inwards New York. I looked at her puzzled in addition to she sheepishly admitted that was unopen to other bastion of elitism. Then she told me she wanted to laid out her ain company. I wished her luck. She was charming inwards her hypocrisy.
This placard best summarized the crowd:
Our economic scheme could endure "more fair" is a reasonable tilt of want or fifty-fifty fact - but it contains no prescription at all. The U.S.A. has had times of high income inequality (the Guilded Age, now) in addition to times of lower income inequality. And I create non want to state it was the New Deal or anything else that caused changing income distribution. Income distribution inwards Commonwealth of Australia was flattest at the halt of a really extended catamenia (23 years) of Conservative government. The economic scheme could be to a greater extent than fair. Then 1 time to a greater extent than it could endure less fair.
Somehow nosotros remove maintain developed a winner-takes-a-great-deal economy. I regret non bespeak these people if they begrudged Steve Jobs dying amongst seven billion dollars personal wealth. I somehow doubtfulness it. iPhones were ubiquitous in addition to they clearly believe that Jobs created something that they wanted.
But they would remove maintain universally thought it unreasonable that Wall Street CEOs were hence rich when their banks were bailed out.
In other words they had a thought that the economic scheme could endure to a greater extent than fair in addition to that their Definition of fairness genuinely accords amongst a lot of other Americans. Plenty of people would concur amongst them.
The Tea Party protesters inwards America are also animated past times a feeling that the organisation could endure to a greater extent than fair - equally are the people who protested the Federal Reserve bank. For that affair the (very small) minority at this protestation wanting "socialism" in all probability experience that agency too. The feeling is unifying. The prescriptions equally to what to create well-nigh it are not.
And the puzzling business office of this protestation was that at that topographic point was no consistent prescription in addition to nobody arguing for 1 - hence they were unified past times their mutual feeling in addition to non divided past times their hostility to each other's prescriptions.
In other words similar most Americans they create non remove maintain a practical clue on how to larn the sort of economic scheme they want in addition to the sort of politics they want. And hence they had no agenda at all.
But most Americans don't become to protests. These people become to this strangely unfocused protest. This homo - clearly middle-class in addition to ameliorate dressed said it quite well. He was at this protestation in addition to he simply wanted to tell you lot that. He had no agenda.
I institute the lack of an agenda puzzling equally did 1 life-time protester I talked to (someone who thought that growth-led capitalism would eventually neglect because of environmental problems). He thought it was the most anarchic protestation he had always been to (no leader, no agenda). But hence he thought the nutrient was ameliorate than at whatever protestation he had been to. I repeated the anarchists for adept authorities describe of piece of job to him in addition to he agreed. Then he said, pointing at dinner simply beingness wheeled out, that the nutrient was great. It was also he said anarchists amongst adept government.
John
No comments