Probability: Why You Lot Should Assist Nearly The Nate Silvery Vs. Nassim Taleb Twitter War

From Toward Data Science, Dec. 17:

How tin give notice 2 information experts disagree so much?

An obscure contestation has reared its ugly caput 1 time again this past times month. Two icons of the quantitative analysis community guide keep locked horns on the greatest of world stages, Twitter. You may live on forgiven for non next the controversy: I’ll create a quick review for the uninitiated. All code in addition to information used to create this article tin give notice live on forklifted from this MatrixDS project.

Nate Silver is the co-founder of FiveThirtyEight. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 massively pop information focused weblog that gained fame for its accuracy predicting the outcomes for the U.S. of A. elections inward 2008. Silver generates predictions using a clever poll aggregating technique which accounts for biases, such equally pollsters who exclusively telephone telephone people amongst landlines.

Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 trained statistician, via economics, he directed his passion for baseball game (sabermetrics) in addition to poker analytics into the arena of politics. In fact, the cite FiveThirtyEight is a nod to the lay out of U.S. of A. electoral votes (538 of them). However, the weblog also covers other involvement areas similar sports. Nate sold his weblog to ESPN in addition to took the task of Editor inward Chief. They (ESPN) used it equally a platform to feed their audience amongst forecasts of sporting events, FiveThirtyEight has since moved to ABC. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 routine see to their website is greeted amongst a mix of political in addition to sports articles amongst detailed predictions in addition to information visualizations.

Nate’s forecasting prowess has travel accepted equally canon inward the pop media. He is a routine invitee on many nationally televised shows to verbalize over his predictions during every national election cycle. So it came equally quite a daze when Nassim Taleb, a best-selling author, in addition to quantitative guide chances expert, publicly announced that FiveThirtyEight does non know how to forecast elections properly!

For his part, Taleb has travel extremely successful due to his sharp agreement of probability inward the existent world. His books are both philosophical in addition to technical, amongst a focus on dubiety in addition to risk. Specifically, he believes that the vast bulk of quantitative models used inward exercise create non sufficiently concern human relationship for real-world risk. Instead, they give the illusion of short-term value (like existence accurate inward some well-understood situations) but break the unknowing users to enormous systemic guide chances when they sense situations the models are non designed to understand.

Taleb gained fame, inward part, because he puts his philosophy into activeness past times exposing his wealth. Malcolm Gladwell wrote an article inward the New Yorker on how Taleb turned his philosophy on guide chances into an incredibly successful investment strategy. He has since gained meaning wealth during unforeseen marketplace events such equally the Russian debt default, 9/11, in addition to the fiscal crisis of 2008. Taleb instantly spends much of his fourth dimension writing in addition to deadlifting (I’m jealous of this bit). He is non shy almost telling someone publicly that he disagrees amongst them: One of those people is Nate Silver.

Taleb’s Tweets directed at Silver Nov 2018

However, Silver isn’t taking the insults lying down!

Silver in addition to Taleb, amongst 3 1 G k in addition to 300k followers respectively, create an enormous buzz amongst these exchanges (starting dorsum inward 2016). However, a quick read through the comment threads in addition to you lot volition realize that few people sympathise the arguments. Even Silver himself seems taken off guard past times Taleb’s attack.

I think, however, this is a cracking chance for a information scientific discipline professional person (or aspiring professional) to dig deeper into what is existence said. There are implications on how nosotros select to model in addition to introduce our function inward a reliable in addition to verifiable way. You must create upward one's take away heed for yourself if Taleb has a holler for or is a but some other crazy rich somebody amongst likewise much fourth dimension on his hands....

...MUCH MORE