Coin-Operated Capitalism: Analysis Of The Inner Workings Of Initial Money Offerings.

First the Hat Tip:

The Journal of Things We Like (Lots)–JOTWELL 

 

Extraordinary Popular Delusions in addition to the Madness of ICO Crowdfunding

Oldthinkers unbellyfeel blockchain. We are told that blockchains, cryptocurrencies, in addition to smart contracts are nigh to revolutionize everything. They take fallible humans from every pace where a transaction could become wrong, replacing them alongside the crystalline perfection of software. Result: clarity, certainty, in addition to consummate liberty from censors in addition to tyrants.

And yet nosotros nonetheless don’t larn it. Some oldthinkers mean value that non all rule is tyranny, piece others indicate to the environmentally disastrous costs of blockchain strip mining. And in addition to thus in that place are those of us who mean value that the entire premise of blockchain boosterism is mistaken, because the novel “smart” contracts are non thus unlike from the one-time “dumb” contracts. Coin-Operated Capitalism, past times a squad of 4 authors from the University of Pennsylvania, is the best recent entry inwards this vein. It is a playful, precise, in addition to damning await at how smart contracts really piece of work inwards the existent world.

This is ane of really few law-and-computer scientific discipline articles that takes both sides of the “and” seriously, in addition to is ane of the best examples I conduct hold e'er seen of what this plain tin be. It is a law-review article nigh an empirical report of contracts in addition to software. To quote the star footnote’s description of the authors’ combined expertise, “Cohney is a fifth-year doctoral pupil inwards calculator in addition to data scientific discipline at the University of Pennsylvania, where Hoffman is a Professor of Law, Sklaroff received a JD/MBA inwards 2018, in addition to Wishnick is a beau inwards the Center for Technology, Innovation in addition to Competition.” (Jeremy Sklaroff, the (alphabetically) 3rd author, wrote an unusually goodness law-review comment on smart contracts final year.) Another nine research assistants helped, presumably alongside the extensive white-paper reading in addition to coding. It takes a hamlet to write a genuinely interdisciplinary article.

Coin-Operated Capitalism’s target is the initial money offering (ICO). As the bring upward suggests, an ICO is a blockchain analogue to a corporate initial world offering (IPO) of equity shares. Instead of receiving stock inwards a novel business, an ICO investor receives tokens that laissez passer her a stake inwards a novel smart contract. The token typically gives the holder simply about transactional rights (the authors’ instance is to have sodas from vending machines) in addition to simply about command rights (e.g. to vote on investment opportunities, or to approve modifications to simply about of the price of the ICO contract), both of which are coded into the smart contract. The promoters work the funds thereby raised for the associated enterprise (e.g., edifice in addition to filling the vending machines), for the evolution in addition to maintenance of the smart contract itself, in addition to sometimes for farther investments equally directed past times the novel shape of token-holders.

Anyone who has e'er heard of securities police trace should hold upward hearing alert bells at this point....

...MORE

And the newspaper via the Social Science Research Network:

Coin-Operated Capitalism

Columbia Law Review, Forthcoming
U of Penn, Inst for Law & Econ Research Paper No. 18-37

105 Pages Posted: eighteen Jul 2018 Last revised: xi December 2018

Abstract

This Article presents the legal literature’s initiatory off detailed analysis of the inner workings of Initial Coin Offerings. We characterize the ICO equally an instance of fiscal innovation, placing it inwards kinship alongside enterprise working capital missive of the alphabet contracting, property securitization, in addition to (obviously) the IPO. We too accept the shape seriously equally an instance of technological innovation, where promoters are kickoff to effectuate their promises to investors through calculator code, rather than traditional contract. To empathize the dynamics of this shift, nosotros initiatory off collect contracts, “white papers,” in addition to other contract-like documents for the 50 top-grossing ICOs of 2017. We in addition to thus analyze how such projects’ software code reflected (or failed to reflect) their contractual promises. Our query reveals that many ICOs failed fifty-fifty to hope that they would protect investors against insider self-dealing. Fewer nonetheless manifested such contracts inwards code. Surprisingly, inwards a community known for espousing a technolibertarian belief inwards the ability of “trustless trust” built alongside carefully designed code, a meaning fraction of issuers retained centralized command through previously undisclosed code permitting alteration of the entities’ governing structures. These findings offering valuable lessons to legal scholars, economists, in addition to policymakers nigh the roles played past times gatekeepers; nigh the value of regulation; in addition to the possibilities for socially valuable somebody ordering inwards a relatively anonymous, decentralized environment. 

SSRN download page