Cities Together With States Battle To Command 5G, Ooops, Hither Come Upwards The Feds

Turf war!!!
H5N1 twofer. initiative of all up, a deep dive from Governing.com, September 18, 2018:

Battle of 5G
The newest mesh engineering scientific discipline has a various cast of characters hoping to command it

Back inward 2016, several major telephone carriers approached the metropolis of McAllen, Texas, nearly edifice state-of-the-art 5G wireless networks. With the hope of ultra-fast mesh connector speeds as well as an array of potential commercial as well as world applications, metropolis officials eagerly entered into discussions nearly amending local ordinances to adapt the necessary infrastructure. Months later, they were to a greater extent than or less reaching an understanding on establishing a large-scale airplane pilot program.

It all started to unravel, though, when McAllen as well as other Texas cities heard nearly a proposal inward the legislature setting statewide rules for 5G installation as well as prohibiting local governments from negotiating their ain deals. McAllen City Attorney Kevin Pagan says the wireless providers initially assured him they weren’t interested inward bespeak for province legislative help. But as well as then the neb started gaining traction. Company representatives stopped responding to Pagan’s emails nearly the licensing agreement, as well as he says he hasn’t heard from them since.

The legislation sailed through both chambers as well as was signed into police in conclusion spring. McAllen has joined other Texas cities equally Pb plaintiff inward suing the province over the bill. “I’d similar to say it was a fight, but when the score has already been determined inward advance earlier the starting gun goes off, it’s hard to telephone yell upwardly it a fight,” Pagan says. “Nothing that nosotros suggested of whatsoever kernel was [included] inward S.B. 1004.”

Across the country, telecom companies are showtime to lay the groundwork for 5G wireless networks. The buildout often pits states against cities, equally inward Texas. But a proposal that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is laid to vote on Sept. 26 would non only upend futurity local agreements, but likewise preempt states. If approved, localities across the dry ground would accept drastically less potency over 5G infrastructure.

The arrival of 5G represents a major advancement inward wireless technology. It’s expected to supply speeds at to the lowest degree 10 times faster than the typical 4G connector that many places at nowadays have. Testing is underway inward choose cities, as well as the FCC volition start auctioning licenses for 5G spectrum inward November. The initiative of all 5G-compatible smartphones are expected to follow adjacent year.

Some localities are already looking to utilisation the engineering scientific discipline inward ways that snuff it good beyond improving mesh speeds. Kansas City, Mo., partnered alongside Cisco as well as Sprint on edifice a world Wi-Fi network roofing constituent of the city’s downtown. It supports pedestrian sensors as well as interactive kiosks along a streetcar line. Bob Bennett, Kansas City’s primary excogitation officer, envisions a litany of potential futurity applications ane time 5G is enabled. Air character as well as temperature sensors detecting pollution, he says, could play a role inward determining where kids hold back for buses. Others accept hailed 5G equally crucial for transmitting information to autonomous vehicles.

The telephone substitution edifice blocks of 5G networks are small-cell antennas interwoven throughout metropolis infrastructure, affixed to streetlights, utility poles or buildings. Providers typically depict them equally the size of pizza boxes. But inward actuality some of the antennas are much larger, spell others are hardly noticeable at all. They to a greater extent than often than non demand to physically connect to wireline fiber, so the initiative of all places expected to larn 5G are densely populated urban areas alongside high consumer demand as well as existing fiber networks. One study conducted past times the municipal advocacy grouping Next Century Cities, of jurisdictions considered to last leaders inward technology, reported that sixty per centum of communities alongside a wireline fiber connector to residences had minor cells inward place, spell the same was truthful of only a tertiary of those without existing fiber.

Unlike mobile telephone towers, small-cell nodes accept express make as well as pathetic might to send signals through physical barriers. So telecoms may demand to install hundreds of minor cells to embrace a relatively minor surface area -- an task that becomes cost-prohibitive inward less urbanized areas. For this reason, Blair Levin, a old FCC official who oversaw the National Broadband Plan, says 5G is probable to farther widen the digital separate that has disadvantaged parts of rural America.

Supporters of the FCC proposal as well as province laws governing 5G ofttimes hold that the laws volition speed upwardly construction, equally good equally potentially facilitate its utilisation inward currently unserved areas. In their pitches to Nebraska province lawmakers in conclusion year, lobbyists argued that a statewide dominion would accelerate rural deployment. Citing comments provided past times telecom providers, the FCC proposal similarly concluded that “resources consumed inward serving ane geographic surface area are probable to deplete the resources available for serving other areas.”

But local officials struggle that carriers won’t convey their 5G networks to outlying areas absent marketplace demand. “There is non a shred of evidence that suggests a penny saved inward New York straightaway gets invested inward Montana,” Levin says. McAllen’s Pagan adds that his metropolis offered companies a “healthy subsidy” to deploy mesh service inward unserved areas, but they weren’t interested....MUCH MORE

And from The Register, September 28, some other deep dive:

Eat my shorts, watchdog tells every metropolis mayor inward the United States of America – FCC approves $2bn 5G telco windfall
The Simpsons meets next-gen mobile broadband policies

If y'all were to selection a minute inward which America's telecoms regulator disappeared downward the rabbit hole at its monthly meeting, it would belike last when the chairman of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Ajit Pai provided a total "up is down" statement.

"I salute Commissioner Carr for his leadership inward developing this order," Pai said today of his beau commissioner Brendan Carr spell discussing a project design to laid a federal trammel on what local as well as province governments are allowed to accuse telecoms companies to add together novel 5G mobile jail στοιχείο sites on their property.

"He worked real closely alongside many province as well as local officials to sympathise their needs as well as to study the policies that accept worked at the province as well as local level. It should hence come upwardly equally no surprise that this guild has won pregnant back upwardly from mayor, local officials as well as province legislatures."

There's only ane work alongside this statement: it is wholly, provable incorrect.

In fact, the FCC only shut a brusk world comment menses inward which a real large let out of mayors, metropolis officials, as well as province legislatures explicitly stated the opposite: that they were only opposed to the plan.

You tin give notice read the letters. They are online. Among the cities implacably opposed to the measure: New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Philadelphia, Chicago, Las Vegas, San Diego, Seattle, Cincinnati, as well as Delaware.

And how just does Pai say mayors back upwardly the project design when his ain purpose received a missive of the alphabet the United States of America Conference of Mayors that began: "The Order establishes an unreasonable as well as unworkable criterion of what constitutes an effective prohibition, which volition impose costs on local governments as well as interfere alongside world security as well as other local protections that are the oculus of localism"?...

...MUCH MORE

You should belike read it, nosotros are going to accept a examination at the terminate of the quarter as well as understanding the politicking volition occupation organisation human relationship for 20% of the in conclusion aeroplane on the interplay betwixt technocracy, politics, technology, surveillance, as well as old-fashioned lust for loot.