The U.S., China In Addition To The Thucydides Trap

From the Boston Globe, May 7:

H5N1 HUNDRED YEARS AGO, World War I was entering its lastly phase. No i inwards either Berlin or London had laid out to expend therefore vast a quantity of blood in addition to treasure on 4 years of industrialized slaughter. As I argued 20 years agone inwards “The Pity of War,” World War I was perchance the greatest error of modern history.

Historians ofttimes hold off dorsum to the events of the 1890s in addition to 1900s inwards an endeavor to delineate the origins of the Anglo-German antagonism. The long-established narrative goes something similar this: The High German economic scheme was overtaking the British economy, a tendency summed upwardly inwards the words “Made inwards Germany” that were stamped on a ascent proportion of imported manufactures.

Deutschland had regal ambitions, too, acquiring colonies inwards Asia in addition to Africa. And it was edifice a fleet that was patently intended to contender the Royal Navy.

Increasingly, every bit their economic scheme boomed, the Germans argued that their political organisation — inwards which the parliament (the Reichstag) had much less ability than its British equivalent, in addition to the monarch much to a greater extent than ability — was intrinsically superior. Their cloth successes bolstered an already deep-rooted nationalism.

The ultimate lawsuit was that United Kingdom of Great Britain in addition to Northern Ireland of Britain in addition to Northern Republic of Ireland in addition to Deutschland followed the ancient representative of Sparta in addition to Athens: the incumbent ability in addition to the ascent ability ended upwardly going to war. The Harvard political scientist Graham Allison calls it the “Thucydides trap,” after the historian of the Peloponnesian War.

Are the the States in addition to mainland People's Republic of China on the means to repeating this classic historical mistake? Having only spent a fascinating calendar week inwards Beijing in addition to Shanghai, I fright they may be.
China’s economic scheme has already, past times at to the lowest degree i measure, overtaken that of the United States. The Chinese receive got come upwardly up with a strategy to grab upwardly inwards price of technology, too. It’s called “Made inwards mainland People's Republic of China 2025.”

President Xi Jinping has his ain version of the Germans’ regal Weltpolitik: the Belt in addition to Road Initiative, which implies a global expansion of Chinese infrastructure in addition to influence.

The People’s Liberation Army is busily edifice upwardly its forces, with the goal (as i Chinese official told me lastly week) of having the world’s strongest military machine past times the fourth dimension the People’s Republic celebrates its centenary, inwards 2049.

Like the Germans a century ago, the Chinese no longer worry that Anglophone republic mightiness live superior to their political system. As for nationalism, in that location is no mistaking its growing importance, specially on social media. “There is also a Chinese populism,” I was warned.

Yet, every bit the events of 1918 proved, Deutschland overestimated itself in addition to underestimated Britain. I fright unopen to Chinese are start to brand this error nigh the United States, with the encouragement of other Asians. My old friend Kishore Mahbubani, formerly Singapore’s representative at the United Nations, has only published a punchy piddling mass entitled “Has the West Lost It?” His respond is a blunt “Yes.” 

...MORE

I suppose it's fourth dimension to dust off Barbara Tuchman's books on the run-up to World War I.
The Proud Tower: H5N1 Portrait of the World Before the War, 1890-1914 derives its championship from a line inwards the Edgar Allen Poe poem  "The City inwards the Sea":

 "While from a proud tower inwards the town/ Death looks gigantically down."

The other, The Guns of August was i of Tuchman's 2 Pulitzer prize-winners It begins:

1

A Funeral

So GORGEOUS was the spectacle on the May morning time of 1910 when nine kings rode inwards the funeral of Edward VII of England that the crowd, waiting inwards hushed in addition to black-clad awe, could non overstep along dorsum gasps of admiration. In scarlet in addition to bluish in addition to greenish in addition to purple, iii past times iii the sovereigns rode through the palace gates, with plumed helmets, golden braid, crimson sashes, in addition to jeweled orders flashing inwards the sun. After them came 5 heirs apparent, 40 to a greater extent than regal or royal highnesses, 7 queens—four dowager in addition to iii regnant—and a scattering of special ambassadors from uncrowned countries. Together they represented 70 nations inwards the greatest assemblage of royalty in addition to rank ever gathered inwards i house and, of its kind, the last. The muffled natural language of Big Ben tolled nine past times the clock every bit the cortege left the palace, but on history’s clock it was sunset, in addition to the Sun of the old basis was setting inwards a dying blaze of splendor never to live seen again.

In the pump of the front end row rode the novel king, George V, flanked on his left past times the Duke of Connaught, the tardily king’s exclusively surviving brother, in addition to on his correct past times a personage to whom, acknowledged The Times, “belongs the maiden off house amid all the unusual mourners,” who “even when relations are most strained has never lost his popularity with us”—William II, the High German Emperor. Mounted on a greyness horse, wearing the scarlet uniform of a British Field Marshal, carrying the baton of that rank, the Kaiser had composed his features behind the famous upturned mustache inwards an aspect “grave fifty-fifty to severity.” Of the several emotions churning his susceptible breast, unopen to hints be inwards his letters. “I am proud to telephone telephone this house my dwelling trouble solid in addition to to live a fellow member of this royal family,” he wrote dwelling trouble solid after spending the nighttime inwards Windsor Castle inwards the old apartments of his mother. Sentiment in addition to nostalgia induced past times these melancholy occasions with his English linguistic communication relatives jostled with pride inwards his supremacy amid the assembled potentates in addition to with a tearing taste inwards the disappearance of his uncle from the European scene. He had come upwardly to bury Edward his bane; Edward the arch plotter, every bit William conceived it, of Germany’s encirclement; Edward his mother’s blood brother whom he could neither great nor impress, whose fatty figure cast a shadow betwixt Deutschland in addition to the sun. “He is Satan. You cannot imagine what a Satan he is!”

This verdict, announced past times the Kaiser earlier a dinner of iii hundred guests inwards Berlin inwards 1907, was occasioned past times i of Edward’s continental tours undertaken with clearly diabolical designs at encirclement. He had spent a provocative calendar week inwards Paris, visited for no skillful ground the King of Kingdom of Spain (who had only married his niece), in addition to finished with a watch to the King of Italy with obvious intent to seduce him from his Triple Alliance with Deutschland in addition to Austria. The Kaiser, owner of the to the lowest degree inhibited natural language inwards Europe, had worked himself into a frenzy ending inwards unopen to other of those comments that had periodically over the past times 20 years of his reign shattered the nerves of diplomats.

Happily the Encircler was directly dead in addition to replaced past times George who, the Kaiser told Theodore Roosevelt a few days earlier the funeral, was “a real overnice boy” (of forty-five, half dozen years younger than the Kaiser). “He is a thorough Englishman in addition to hates all foreigners but I create non heed that every bit long every bit he does non abhor Germans to a greater extent than than other foreigners.” Alongside George, William directly rode confidently, saluting every bit he passed the regimental colors of the 1st Royal Dragoons of which he was honorary colonel. Once he had distributed photographs of himself wearing their uniform with the Delphic inscription written inwards a higher house his signature, “I bide my time.” Today his fourth dimension had come; he was supreme inwards Europe.

Behind him rode the widowed Queen Alexandra’s 2 brothers, King Frederick of Kingdom of Denmark in addition to King George of the Hellenes; her nephew, King Haakon of Norway; in addition to iii kings who were to lose their thrones: Alfonso of Spain, Manuel of Portugal and, wearing a silk turban, King Ferdinand of Republic of Bulgaria who annoyed his swain sovereigns past times calling himself Czar in addition to kept inwards a thorax a Byzantine Emperor’s total regalia, acquired from a theatrical costumer, against the hateful solar daytime when he should reassemble the Byzantine dominions beneath his scepter.

Dazzled past times these “splendidly mounted princes,” as The Times called them, few observers had eyes for the 9th king, the exclusively i amid them who was to accomplish greatness every bit a man. Despite his great elevation in addition to perfect horsemanship, Albert, King of the Belgians, who disliked the pomp of royal ceremony, contrived inwards that fellowship to hold off both embarrassed in addition to absentminded. He was therefore thirty-five in addition to had been on the throne barely a year. In after years when his human face upwardly became known to the basis every bit a symbol of heroism in addition to tragedy, it nevertheless e'er wore that abstracted look, every bit if his heed were on something else.

The time to come source of tragedy, tall, corpulent, in addition to corseted, with greenish plumes waving from his helmet, Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria, heir of the old Emperor Franz Josef, rode on Albert’s right, in addition to on his left unopen to other scion who would never gain his throne, Prince Yussuf, heir of the Sultan of Turkey. After the kings came the royal highnesses: Prince Fushimi, blood brother of the Emperor of Japan; Grand Duke Michael, blood brother of the Czar of Russia; the Duke of Aosta inwards brilliant bluish with greenish plumes, blood brother of the King of Italy; Prince Carl, blood brother of the King of Sweden; Prince Henry, consort of the Queen of Holland; in addition to the Crown Princes of Serbia, Rumania, in addition to Montenegro. The lastly named, Prince Danilo, “an amiable, extremely handsome immature human being of delightful manners,” resembled the Merry Widow’s lover inwards to a greater extent than than name, for, to the consternation of British functionaries, he had arrived the nighttime earlier accompanied past times a “charming immature lady of great personal attractions” whom he introduced every bit his wife’s lady inwards waiting with the explanation that she had come upwardly to London to create unopen to shopping.

A regiment of fry High German royalty followed: rulers of Mecklenburg-Schwerin, Mecklenburg-Strelitz, Waldeck-Pyrmont, Saxe-Coburg Gotha, of Saxony, Hesse, Württemberg, Baden, in addition to Bavaria, of whom the last, Crown Prince Rupprecht, was presently to Pb a High German regular army inwards battle. There were a Prince of Siam, a Prince of Persia, 5 princes of the old French royal trouble solid of Orléans, a blood brother of the Khedive of Arab Republic of Egypt wearing a gold-tasseled fez, Prince Tsia-tao of mainland People's Republic of China inwards an embroidered light-blue gown whose ancient dynasty had 2 to a greater extent than years to run, in addition to the Kaiser’s brother, Prince Henry of Prussia, representing the High German Navy, of which he was Commander inwards Chief. Amid all this magnificence were iii civilian-coated gentlemen, M. Gaston-Carlin of Switzerland, M. Pichon, Foreign Minister of France, in addition to old President Theodore Roosevelt, special envoy of the United States.

Edward, the object of this unprecedented gathering of nations, was ofttimes called the “Uncle of Europe,” a championship which, insofar every bit Europe’s ruling houses were meant, could live taken literally. He was the uncle non exclusively of Kaiser Wilhelm but also, through his wife’s sister, the Dowager Empress Marie of Russia, of Czar Nicolas II. His ain niece Alix was the Czarina; his missy Maud was Queen of Norway; unopen to other niece, Ena, was Queen of Spain; a 3rd niece, Marie, was presently to live Queen of Rumania. The Danish household unit of measurement of his wife, likewise occupying the throne of Denmark, had mothered the Czar of Russian Federation in addition to supplied kings to Hellenic Republic in addition to Norway. Other relatives, the progeny at diverse removes of Queen Victoria’s nine sons in addition to daughters, were scattered inwards abundance throughout the courts of Europe....

We used that funeral every bit the introduction to 2011's "Seating Charts are Such a Pain: Soros in addition to the Starlet":
Sometimes it's easy:
You whistle upwardly your Protocol peeps in addition to inwards iii minutes y'all get

Nine Kings 1910

 

That is likely the exclusively photograph of nine reigning monarchs ever taken.*

Sometimes it is to a greater extent than difficult:...

*May 1910: Nine Kings assembled at Buckingham Palace for the funeral of Edward VII, the Father of George V (centre). From left to right, dorsum row: Haakon VII of Norway, Ferdinand I of Bulgaria, Manuel II of Portugal, Wilhelm II of Germany, George I of Hellenic Republic in addition to Albert I Of Belgium. Front row: Alphonso XIII of Spain, George V in addition to Frederick VIII of Denmark. The funeral on  20th May was the largest gathering of the European royalty–and its lastly hurrah, too. Also nowadays at the funeral was Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria, whose assassination four years later would spark the WWI–which collapsed many royal dynasties of Europe. Manuel of Portugal would live driven from his throne past times revolutionaries inside months of this picture. George would be assassinated.  Alphonso, Wilhelm in addition to Ferdinand lost their thrones.-Source

You've likely noted the absence of Nicholas II, Emperor in addition to Autocrat of All the Russias.
Very strange considering that he was part o'the fam:

King George V (right) with his

maiden off cousin Tsar Nicholas II, 

Berlin, 1913. Note the close 

physical resemblance between 

the 2 monarchs.

-Wikipedia

Things change....