Post-Truth Together With Propaganda

A long read on why it is fourth dimension the residuum of the media stopped treating Fox equally TV news, in addition to some UK tabloids equally newspapers.

George Osborne becomes editor of the London Evening Standard. Donald Trump blames GCHC for bugging him because of something he saw on Fox News. The lines betwixt correct fly media in addition to correct fly politicians seem rattling blurred nowadays. This should non come upwards equally a surprise, because correct fly media receive got been becoming much to a greater extent than similar propaganda outlets than normal media organisations for some time. The conventions of journalism may receive got pretended otherwise, but it fourth dimension nosotros recognised reality.

Let me define ii archetypes. The first, which could endure called the truth purveyor, is the 1 nosotros are familiar with, in addition to which much of the mainstream media (MSM) similar to imagine they correspond to. The aim is provide the best information to readers or viewers. The minute is propaganda. One way of characterising the ii archetypes is equally follows. Readers receive got sure interests: objectives, goals, utilities etc. The truth purveyor volition provide readers with the information they demand to pursue those interests. (As exemplified here, for example.) Propaganda on the other hand, to borrow from Jacob Stanley, aims to provide information that volition deceive people from seeing what is inwards their best interest. Propaganda provides information that supports a item political goal or betoken of view.

Take, for example, the number of welfare benefits. Media equally the truth-purveyor type volition essay in addition to acquaint a rounded in addition to accurate moving-picture exhibit of those claiming welfare benefits. Right fly propaganda on the other mitt volition focus on examples of do goodness fraud, or cases where the do goodness recipient volition endure perceived past times the reader equally taking wages of the system, with piffling or no sweat to position the representative inwards whatever variety of context. This slanted coverage is designed to give the impression that do goodness recipients are oft scroungers in addition to skivers. The political goal is to acquire inwards easier for governments to cutting welfare payments, which inwards plough may allows taxes to endure cut.

These are archetypes, in addition to whatever media organisation volition mix the ii to some extent. Many would debate that fifty-fifty the most truth-purveyor type organisation may yet embody sure assumptions or points of take in that distort their readers take in of what should endure inwards their best interest. (As argued inwards Manufacturing Consent, for example.) Mediamacro is an representative of this. But that should non blind us to what is happening elsewhere. Lines similar “liberals’ nostalgia for factual politics seems designed to mask their ain fraught human relationship with the truth” [1] advise aught novel is happening, let’s displace on. That would endure a huge mistake. It is similar maxim all tidings is propaganda, who cares. But because at that topographic point are ii archetypes, organisations tin gradually displace from 1 to another, in addition to that motility is important. It played a crucial go inwards the success of Brexit in addition to Trump.

In both inwards the UK in addition to the States at that topographic point is a large constituent of the media which is becoming to a greater extent than in addition to to a greater extent than similar a pure propaganda outlet. We are used to thinking most propaganda equally beingness associated with the state, but at that topographic point is no ground why that has to endure the case. In the UK in addition to US, nosotros directly receive got propaganda machines that back upwards political ideas that are associated with the far right, in addition to political interests associated with the rattling wealthy. Their output is governed to a greater extent than in addition to to a greater extent than past times whether it assists those ii goals.

Apologists for this correct fly propaganda say that most media organisations receive got their item political bias, in addition to that volition endure reflected inwards the opinions yous encounter inwards that media outlet. But I’m non talking most sentiment pieces or leaders, but most the pick of stories in addition to increasingly most making upwards stories. I cannot encounter either the Guardian, Mirror or MSNBC alone reporting terrorist incidents past times white supremacists, in addition to ignoring those past times Muslims. Nor would these organisations build upwards claims most unusual cities beingness ‘no go out areas’. Suggesting an equivalence betwixt The Mail in addition to The Mirror, or betwixt Fox in addition to MSNBC, is a trap that many autumn into.

Now it is natural, inwards a liberal democracy, that the constituent of the media that conveys propaganda should pretend it is just a purveyor of truth. When its propaganda becomes self-evident, it is besides natural for it to claim that this is because it is others who are distorting the facts. In this sense, the fact that Trump in addition to his supporters verbalise most the dominant liberal media producing faux news, in addition to the correct fly tabloids verbalise about bias at the BBC should non worry us at all. It is just indicative that those making the allegations are inwards the work organisation of, or supporting those, supplying propaganda. [2] More importantly, if nosotros allow this sweat at deflection to displace us away from examining what dissimilar parts of the media are doing, in addition to so the propagandists receive got won.

………………………………………………………………………….

I recall it was Charlie Bean who starting fourth dimension told me most the stupidity of a theatre announcing that it was going to receive got to build redundancies, without specifying where those redundancies would be. It is foolish because the atmosphere of dubiousness created agency that those most able to leave, who are almost for certain the brightest in addition to best in addition to so those that the theatre would similar to keep, destination upwards leaving the theatre because they can. Voluntary quits hateful the theatre no longer needs to create redundancies, but its loses its best character staff to other firms.

I thought most this when reading most yet to a greater extent than examples of how European Union citizens are currently beingness treated past times this government. Colin Talbot has documented what is going on here, but at that topographic point are literally thousands of similar stories. People who receive got lived in addition to worked inwards the UK for years are told past times the dwelling office, when their application for permanent residence is turned down, to gear upwards to leave of absence the UK. Applications which inquire for a ridiculous amount of information in addition to are turned downwards for oft mindless reasons. It is a scheme designed to growth the chances that applicants volition fail.

The result this has, of course, is that those most able to leave of absence the UK, who volition oft endure the most able inwards damage of the importance of the piece of work they do, volition go. Refusing to confirm the rights of European Union residents in addition to sending them scary letters is how the UK authorities is making the same fault equally the theatre that announces time to come unspecified redundancies. I am sometimes told that Brexit volition allow the UK to select the ‘best immigrants’, the ones that volition contribute most to UK output in addition to the populace purse. Here nosotros encounter Brexit achieving just the opposite: a scheme designed to encourage the best to leave.

But this is non a novel Brexit phenomenon. As I described here, students wanting to come upwards in addition to study inwards the UK receive got faced a similar fell regime, where a fault past times the UK bureaucracy - fifty-fifty when it is acknowledged equally such - tin atomic number 82 to additional expense for the pupil in addition to a catamenia of dubiousness which tin alone laid dorsum their learning. Students midway through their course of study are told they receive got lx days to detect an option establishment to sponsor them or human face upwards deportation. The UK Border Agency has no ground to believe that these are non perfectly genuine students who receive got paid proficient coin to study inwards the UK, but it chooses to punish them because of alleged failings past times a university.

There is an obvious pattern here. It is to process those who are non UK nationals with a consummate lack of humanity. It is, quite simply, rattling cruel. I talked inwards a higher house most how counterproductive it is, but fifty-fifty if it was non it remains rattling wrong. It is non something that whatever democratic authorities should do. Similar things are here, but at that topographic point are literally thousands of similar stories. People who receive got lived in addition to worked inwards the UK for years are told past times the dwelling office, when their application for permanent residence is turned down, to gear upwards to leave of absence the UK. Applications which inquire for a ridiculous amount of information in addition to are turned downwards for oft mindless reasons. It is a scheme designed to growth the chances that applicants volition fail.

The result this has, of course, is that those most able to leave of absence the UK, who volition oft endure the most able inwards damage of the importance of the piece of work they do, volition go. Refusing to confirm the rights of European Union residents in addition to sending them scary letters is how the UK authorities is making the same fault equally the theatre that announces time to come unspecified redundancies. I am sometimes told that Brexit volition allow the UK to select the ‘best immigrants’, the ones that volition contribute most to UK output in addition to the populace purse. Here nosotros encounter Brexit achieving just the opposite: a scheme designed to encourage the best to leave.

But this is non a novel Brexit phenomenon. As I described here, these ii papers printed on average ii or 3 hostile immigration stories inwards each number inwards 2016. The hateful solar daytime earlier polling, the Mail printed 6 whole pages devoted to immigration. You would receive got to endure a fool to believe these were ‘reflecting the involvement of readers’: it was here, but at that topographic point are literally thousands of similar stories. People who receive got lived in addition to worked inwards the UK for years are told past times the dwelling office, when their application for permanent residence is turned down, to gear upwards to leave of absence the UK. Applications which inquire for a ridiculous amount of information in addition to are turned downwards for oft mindless reasons. It is a scheme designed to growth the chances that applicants volition fail.

The result this has, of course, is that those most able to leave of absence the UK, who volition oft endure the most able inwards damage of the importance of the piece of work they do, volition go. Refusing to confirm the rights of European Union residents in addition to sending them scary letters is how the UK authorities is making the same fault equally the theatre that announces time to come unspecified redundancies. I am sometimes told that Brexit volition allow the UK to select the ‘best immigrants’, the ones that volition contribute most to UK output in addition to the populace purse. Here nosotros encounter Brexit achieving just the opposite: a scheme designed to encourage the best to leave.

But this is non a novel Brexit phenomenon. As I described designed to force the plebiscite vote the way these papers wanted. It was pure propaganda.

…………………………………………………………………………..

The are lots of stories around most a post-truth basis created past times social media. It is normally written upwards equally if it is a novel phenomenon created past times novel technology, but equally Timothy Garton Ash notes ‘post-truth’ is aught new. Equally the hype over Cambridge Analytica (here or here), whether it is accurate or not, is just the technological extension of something that is already happening, in addition to has happened inwards the past. Most people yet rely on the MSM for their news. Post-truth mainly comes from the constituent of the MSM whose work organisation is propaganda, in addition to the inability of others to process it equally such. Fake tidings stories on social media did not win the election for Trump. Fox News almost here, but at that topographic point are literally thousands of similar stories. People who receive got lived in addition to worked inwards the UK for years are told past times the dwelling office, when their application for permanent residence is turned down, to gear upwards to leave of absence the UK. Applications which inquire for a ridiculous amount of information in addition to are turned downwards for oft mindless reasons. It is a scheme designed to growth the chances that applicants volition fail.

The result this has, of course, is that those most able to leave of absence the UK, who volition oft endure the most able inwards damage of the importance of the piece of work they do, volition go. Refusing to confirm the rights of European Union residents in addition to sending them scary letters is how the UK authorities is making the same fault equally the theatre that announces time to come unspecified redundancies. I am sometimes told that Brexit volition allow the UK to select the ‘best immigrants’, the ones that volition contribute most to UK output in addition to the populace purse. Here nosotros encounter Brexit achieving just the opposite: a scheme designed to encourage the best to leave.

But this is non a novel Brexit phenomenon. As I described certainly did.

As Tim Harford here, but at that topographic point are literally thousands of similar stories. People who receive got lived in addition to worked inwards the UK for years are told past times the dwelling office, when their application for permanent residence is turned down, to gear upwards to leave of absence the UK. Applications which inquire for a ridiculous amount of information in addition to are turned downwards for oft mindless reasons. It is a scheme designed to growth the chances that applicants volition fail.

The result this has, of course, is that those most able to leave of absence the UK, who volition oft endure the most able inwards damage of the importance of the piece of work they do, volition go. Refusing to confirm the rights of European Union residents in addition to sending them scary letters is how the UK authorities is making the same fault equally the theatre that announces time to come unspecified redundancies. I am sometimes told that Brexit volition allow the UK to select the ‘best immigrants’, the ones that volition contribute most to UK output in addition to the populace purse. Here nosotros encounter Brexit achieving just the opposite: a scheme designed to encourage the best to leave.

But this is non a novel Brexit phenomenon. As I described explains, is for policy makers non to autumn into the trap of appeasement.

“Christina Boswell in addition to James Hampshire receive got highlighted how the populace discourse on immigration inwards Federal Republic of Federal Republic of Germany was transformed betwixt 2000 in addition to 2008. Social Democratic politicians used familiar arguments most the economical benefits of immigration. But they did this amongst a create to promote positive narratives most immigration in addition to its house inwards the country’s history to counter entrenched perceptions of Federal Republic of Federal Republic of Germany beingness kein Einwanderunglsand (“not a province of immigration”). This twin approach largely succeeded inwards changing attitudes, flowering inwards the generous seat taken past times Angela Merkel’s Christian Democrat authorities towards Syrian refugees inwards the summertime of 2015.

By contrast inwards the UK, at the same time, Labour began to verbalise upwards “British jobs for British workers” in addition to never seriously rebutted the dominant in addition to dismal narrative of the tabloid press most immigration beingness an economical burden in addition to culturally corrosive, arguably helping to laid the scene for the electrical flow bout of self-harming Brexit-related xenophobia.”

Now politicians hither may answer that the High German representative is impossible given the forcefulness of the propaganda coming from UK tabloids (compared to its relative absence inwards Germany), but that just strengthens my betoken that nosotros should commence recognising that propaganda for what it is. That recognition needs to commence inwards the residuum of the mainstream media. According to a study outlined here, “a right-wing media network anchored around Breitbart developed equally a distinct in addition to insulated media scheme ... This pro-Trump media sphere appears to receive got non alone successfully laid the agenda for the conservative media sphere, but besides strongly influenced the broader media agenda, inwards item coverage of Hillary Clinton.”

But the authors besides banker's complaint that “Our information strongly advise that most Americans, including those who access tidings through social networks, proceed to pay attending to traditional media, next professional person journalistic practices, in addition to cross-reference what they read on partisan sites with what they read on majority media sites.” What this traditional media needs to do, inwards both the UK in addition to US, is to recognise propaganda for what it is, in addition to process it with the disdain that it deserves.

In the the States that is quite a challenge because a lot of that propaganda is directly created or recycled past times the President himself. In the UK it is a challenge because the correct fly tabloids receive got the government’s support, in addition to the authorities holds the travelling pocket strings of the BBC. [4] It is rattling slowly just to ignore what is happening, in addition to send on equally usual. But this inability or unwillingness to recognise the danger posed past times propaganda is constituent of the ground 2016 happened. Liberal democracy’s survival inwards the UK in addition to the States may depend on recognising in addition to resisting what is inwards the procedure of destroying it.

[1] Taken from Stahl in addition to Hansen. The implication that they draw, that propaganda equally tidings or post-truth or whatever yous desire to telephone vociferation upwards it tin endure combatted past times a “democratic revival” seems simply naive. To encounter the profound deviation between, say, the Blair authorities compared to what came earlier in addition to later on them, yous alone receive got to look at how they regarded academics.

[2] For those who say how do nosotros know who is telling the truth, in addition to so yous are constituent of the problem.

[3] And amidst academics, UK nationals equally well. 

[4] And, it seems, increasingly supplies its journalists.