On The Freight Educate - How Create Y'all Value Adidas?
I ain a seat inwards Adidas - the German linguistic communication athletic shoe too fashion company.
Given how good it has performed the seat is nowhere close large enough.
I wishing all my longs had performed this well.
But it poses a fairly typical investment employment for which I bring no existent answers.
--
Background
I volition laissez passer on y'all a real stylised history of how nosotros got here.
Herzogenaurach inwards FRG is a funny (and small) town quite unopen to Nuremberg - too a twosome of hours drive N of Munich.
Once upon a fourth dimension ii brothers started a sports shoe companionship (and it was successful). The brothers dissever upwardly too i blood brother started some other sports shoe company.
Those companies are Adidas too Puma. And for a long fourth dimension they considered each other the enemy.
Then along came Nike too particularly the Michael Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan partnership too basketball game shoes - too exposed Herzo for what it was - an out-of-touch German linguistic communication backwater.
Bluntly the fashion path inwards shoes was from (mostly African American) street wear, to middle-class white street apparel to Cathay (where the affluent to a surprising extent mimicked American fashion). And basketball game shoes were the path to cool.
Sure in that location were some people I knew who went to Wharton who thought Puma was some variety of Euro-elite cool - but frankly the Germans merely missed out.
I went to Herzo to see these companies because they were super-cheap (and for no other reason).
How did I stair out cheap?
These stocks were merely inexpensive against revenue really. Nike - past times far the leader - has a marketplace cap of $85 billion downward from good over $100 billion.
It has a chip of cyberspace cash (reflecting how insanely profitable it is) too well-nigh 33 billion of revenue. The cost is well-nigh 2.5 times sales - but when I went to see Herzo Nike was trading over 3 times sales.
By contrast Puma (which is essentially inwards the same business) has a marketplace cap of €3.5 billion too sales of well-nigh the same. It is roughly 1 times sales. When I went to see Puma was trading at well-nigh 0.6 times sales.
Relative to sales Nike had something to a greater extent than than 5 times the valuation of Puma. This gap has straight off closed a lot.
But too then i time to a greater extent than Nike was (and remains) insanely profitable too Puma merely wasn't.
Adidas was somewhere inwards the middle of these valuations.
If Adidas or Puma could sell shoes at something similar Nike's effective margin too then the German linguistic communication companies would become up. H5N1 lot. An insane lot. Like 5 baggers were on offer.
But too then Adidas too Puma had merely missed the boat. And whilst they had decent positions inwards European fashion (driven past times potent positions inwards what Australians too Americans telephone telephone "soccer") they had meaningless positions inwards America too weak positions inwards China.
Now fashion is non an expanse I have any expertise. This is obvious if y'all come across how I dress.
So I was non probable a buyer. Just kicking the tyres.
The Puma store inwards Beijing
But I soundless wanted to boot the tyres. After all inexpensive is fun - too I am a value investor. So I did construct a betoken of walking merely about Puma too Adidas shops inwards diverse locations, too fifty-fifty counting customers vs. nation local Nike shops.
Most the shops even thence are similar shops on "Fifth Avenue". They are meant equally much equally anything to endure construct advertising rather than to construct a earnings inwards their ain right. So this is soundless alone marginally useful research.
That said I went to the Puma flagship store inwards Beijing - too - amongst a translator - interviewed the staff. I wrote out the impressions inwards an electronic mail to Michael Lämmermann, Puma's CFO - but mostly because I had his electronic mail somewhere inwards the system. Here is that email:
Given how good it has performed the seat is nowhere close large enough.
I wishing all my longs had performed this well.
But it poses a fairly typical investment employment for which I bring no existent answers.
--
Background
I volition laissez passer on y'all a real stylised history of how nosotros got here.
Herzogenaurach inwards FRG is a funny (and small) town quite unopen to Nuremberg - too a twosome of hours drive N of Munich.
Once upon a fourth dimension ii brothers started a sports shoe companionship (and it was successful). The brothers dissever upwardly too i blood brother started some other sports shoe company.
Those companies are Adidas too Puma. And for a long fourth dimension they considered each other the enemy.
Then along came Nike too particularly the Michael Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan partnership too basketball game shoes - too exposed Herzo for what it was - an out-of-touch German linguistic communication backwater.
Bluntly the fashion path inwards shoes was from (mostly African American) street wear, to middle-class white street apparel to Cathay (where the affluent to a surprising extent mimicked American fashion). And basketball game shoes were the path to cool.
Sure in that location were some people I knew who went to Wharton who thought Puma was some variety of Euro-elite cool - but frankly the Germans merely missed out.
I went to Herzo to see these companies because they were super-cheap (and for no other reason).
How did I stair out cheap?
These stocks were merely inexpensive against revenue really. Nike - past times far the leader - has a marketplace cap of $85 billion downward from good over $100 billion.
It has a chip of cyberspace cash (reflecting how insanely profitable it is) too well-nigh 33 billion of revenue. The cost is well-nigh 2.5 times sales - but when I went to see Herzo Nike was trading over 3 times sales.
By contrast Puma (which is essentially inwards the same business) has a marketplace cap of €3.5 billion too sales of well-nigh the same. It is roughly 1 times sales. When I went to see Puma was trading at well-nigh 0.6 times sales.
Relative to sales Nike had something to a greater extent than than 5 times the valuation of Puma. This gap has straight off closed a lot.
But too then i time to a greater extent than Nike was (and remains) insanely profitable too Puma merely wasn't.
Adidas was somewhere inwards the middle of these valuations.
If Adidas or Puma could sell shoes at something similar Nike's effective margin too then the German linguistic communication companies would become up. H5N1 lot. An insane lot. Like 5 baggers were on offer.
But too then Adidas too Puma had merely missed the boat. And whilst they had decent positions inwards European fashion (driven past times potent positions inwards what Australians too Americans telephone telephone "soccer") they had meaningless positions inwards America too weak positions inwards China.
Now fashion is non an expanse I have any expertise. This is obvious if y'all come across how I dress.
So I was non probable a buyer. Just kicking the tyres.
The Puma store inwards Beijing
But I soundless wanted to boot the tyres. After all inexpensive is fun - too I am a value investor. So I did construct a betoken of walking merely about Puma too Adidas shops inwards diverse locations, too fifty-fifty counting customers vs. nation local Nike shops.
Most the shops even thence are similar shops on "Fifth Avenue". They are meant equally much equally anything to endure construct advertising rather than to construct a earnings inwards their ain right. So this is soundless alone marginally useful research.
That said I went to the Puma flagship store inwards Beijing - too - amongst a translator - interviewed the staff. I wrote out the impressions inwards an electronic mail to Michael Lämmermann, Puma's CFO - but mostly because I had his electronic mail somewhere inwards the system. Here is that email:
I bring merely come upwardly dorsum from a operate trip to China.
I wanted to exit y'all impressions of the Puma Shops inwards Beijing too Shenzhen which I spent some fourth dimension looking at.
Beijing is a disaster expanse - real badly run past times surly staff.
This is a fitness companionship too the staff were fat. Not obese - merely pudgy - but they did non await similar they used the products too they did non introduce an icon that would sell the product.
We asked them (in Chinese) how they were employed - too it was from a local staff pool. They were Beijing locals (more expensive) but that was the terminate of it.
This is a province where it is legal to inquire women to ship inwards photos amongst their labor applications too to merely select the prettiest one.
Whatever - fatty staff inwards a sporting goodness store is a actually bad icon - too y'all demand to laid upwardly it.
Fat too rude staff is merely unforgiveable.
--
Shenzhen (Dongman district) was better. The fry behind the counter (only i of them - store was small) looked the role - too was wearing your shoes too looked immature too fit.
He was also helpful to our (very fluent) Chinese speakers inwards the group.
However he was wearing non-Puma rails clothes. Just saying.
--
For the tape - I bring non been convinced plenty to purchase your shares - but they await cheap.
This was merely observation.
I did non teach a reply.
And I bring never touched Puma stock.
--
Enter Kasper Rorsted at Adidas
Adidas got an activist shareholder - i amongst a longer-than-average fourth dimension horizon. This was Groupe Bruxelles Lambert - the belongings companionship of Albert Frere too the belatedly Paul Desmarais. I bring watched GBL for some time.
GBL are soft-cooperative activists inwards the Northern European sense. They tend to teach what they desire cooperatively too like shooting fish in a barrel - oftentimes real slowly.
GBL agitated for too got a novel CEO at Adidas - a Dane named Kasper Rorsted.
We knew him. And I bring thought him pretty darn goodness for a long time. He was the longtime CEO of Henkel (a Munich based industrial gum too consumer goods conglomerate). Henkel was the minute biggest stock at the foundation of - too nosotros bring held it continuously. [Regrettably I sold also much on the way up.]
Kasper mightiness non walk on water. But he is soundless inwards the transcend league of CEOs.
So nosotros bought Adidas stock purely on the speculation. After all Kasper had sense inwards American consumer goods, was a to a greater extent than oftentimes than non goodness guy too the stock was inexpensive plenty on a cost to sales footing that the upside was large.
And the stock has gone up.
In all honesty I create non get to sympathise what Kasper has done that has made this companionship amend - but it sure shows inwards the numbers.
Here is an extract from the final quarterly presentation - y'all can find the link here:
This is a piffling difficult to come across - thence I encourage y'all to download the original. But notation actually squeamish sales growth inwards all jurisdictions too sales growth to a higher house xx percentage inwards both the USA too China.
There is clearly a fashion chemical cistron here. Adidas has a bargain amongst Kanye re shoes. I am thence out of pop civilization I needed to educate myself equally to who Kanye was. (No I am non joking.)
But it can't merely endure Kanye (as the novel Michael Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan no less) because Reebok shoes (also owned past times Adidas) are having similar sales book growth.
Whatever - Adidas is straight off growing explosively.
Take your xx percentage book growth too stick into a valuation spreadsheet too come across what y'all come upwardly up with. This sort of cyberspace introduce value worksheet is similar Hubble telescope. Tweak the directions of diverse variables fifty-fifty a tiny chip too y'all air current upwardly inwards a unlike galaxy.
So nosotros can't value it. We bring no idea.
But nosotros ain the stock. The seat is soundless non enormous (the master copy belongings was a suck-it-and-see speculation on the novel CEO) but the seat is getting bigger too bigger because the stock is doing well.
But nosotros ain the stock. The seat is soundless non enormous (the master copy belongings was a suck-it-and-see speculation on the novel CEO) but the seat is getting bigger too bigger because the stock is doing well.
I don't desire to teach off the train. At to the lowest degree until I come across something negative. So I am looking for negative. Comments wanted.
Sports rights - the novel too increased negative
H5N1 re-energized Adidas is the best affair always if y'all are high profile sports thespian looking for a shoe-deal.
There are straight off ii rich companies wanting to seat shoes on your feet too logos on your body. And that agency bidding wars.
The insane nation of war for the 4 large brands of Castilian football game (Barcelona, Real Madrid, Ronaldo, Messi) is getting just bizarrely expensive.
This is corking for people amongst innate ball skills (which is most sure non me). It is bad for both Adidas too Nike shareholders. I scout inwards horror.
But apart from that I can't (yet) come across the negatives. But too then I bring no fashion sense (at all) thence I mightiness endure the final mortal to see.
John
No comments