Lightsquared - To A Greater Extent Than Or Less Comments
I usually uncovering Senator Charles Grassley's attempts to provoke spats alongside big-name hedge fund managers tendentious. But inward his spat alongside Falcone together with Harbinger he is correct on the money. Lightsquared deserves to neglect together with Grassley knows it.
If yous don't know the background start alongside Bethany McLean's excellent article on Phil together with Lisa Falcone inward Vanity Fair. I remember McLean tries besides difficult to last balanced on the fundamental policy resultant of spectrum together with Lightsquared - but McLean offers a practiced introduction to the issues. By contrast Grassley is non balanced but he is right. Here is why.
There is an international trunk that administers a binding international treaty on how spectrum should last allocated. That trunk is the International Telecommunications Union.
The rules demand to last binding because otherwise 1 country's communications build-out could jam communications from some other country. This is especially of import where countries are densely packed (like Europe) but is also of import inward the Americas especially regarding satellite spectrum. (After all spectrum purpose past times Argentine Republic could interfere alongside spectrum purpose past times the U.S.A. if that spectrum is used past times a geostationary satellite.)
The biggest conflict is betwixt satellite spectrum together with terrestrial spectrum. Satellites are a long way away (in geosynchronous compass they are 35,786 kilometres inward a higher house the equator). Because they are a long way away the signal is non real powerful together with yous oft demand a dish to grab plenty signal to arrive usable. Being a real weak signal yous demand to ensure that at that spot is no real powerful signal inward the same spectral region. H5N1 powerful signal volition block a weak signal simply every bit sure as shooting every bit a large metropolis radio station tin sack drown out a less powerful regional station a piffling farther upward the (frequency) dial.
The ITU's chore is to brand certain this does non happen. The treaty for instance stops Canadian land-based radio devices jamming distant (and thus much weaker) American satellite devices together with vice-versa.
The offset matter the ITU does it allocates some spectrum every bit global spectrum (mostly for satellites but also for communicating alongside ships at body of body of water together with similar) together with other spectrum every bit terrestrial spectrum which fellow member countries tin sack allocate yet they want. After all at that spot is piffling international resultant inward land-based spectrum because interference is basically local. (A jail cellular telephone phone inward New York does non interfere alongside a jail cellular telephone phone inward London or visa-versa – so the allotment of terrestrial spectrum inward London tin sack last done independently of the American Government or vice-versa.)
Generally satellite spectrum is given away or sold real cheaply – but it comes alongside obligations. The primary obligation is to build out some (normally global) social network (eg communication to remote areas or ships at sea). Terrestrial spectrum is auctioned past times local governments together with oft carries the correct to build a jail cellular telephone phone network. That spectrum is hugely valuable together with is auctioned for billions of dollars.
There is an underlying global policy resultant hither – which is that jail cellular telephone phone purpose is growing similar crazy together with the existent shortages of spectrum are for jail cellular telephone phones rather than for satellites. The iPhone together with other network devices are the heart together with individual culprit together with the inability of many of my readers to purpose their iPhone inward New York City is will to that.
In an ideal globe some of the spectrum allocated to satellites would – over fourth dimension – last shifted to domestic purpose together with auctioned past times the local authorities. This can't last done fast because businesses bring satellites inward infinite at the toll of several billion dollars together with yous can't simply homecoming them useless past times drowning their signal alongside (nearer together with thus much stronger) domestic signal.
Enter Phil Faclone together with Lightsquared. Lightsquared gets access to some satellite spectrum cheaply together with so ploughs headlong into a loophole inward spectrum laws. The loophole is this: satellite spectrum licenses let the structure of ground-based booster stations to retransmit their signal together with thus arrive to a greater extent than useful. The instance envisaged is tell a remote town inward Alaska needs a 6 pes dish to have the signal (and thus tell larn high speed internet). Rather than bring everyone inward the town install a vi pes dish they install a unmarried dish together with so retransmit the signal roughly the town – together with that way everyone inward the remote surface area tin sack purpose the signal cheaply. Seems sensible enough.
But inward the eyes of Falcone this gives him the correct to purpose xl chiliad addition booster stations all they way across America so he tin sack retransmit to everyone. Of course of didactics these booster stations volition also last connected to ground-based fibre networks where appropriate. And so Falcone plans to build some other U.S. national jail cellular telephone phone network or at to the lowest degree to sell spectrum to the existing networks.
This is – to position it mildly – audacious. And at that spot is piffling dubiousness that American consumers would do goodness from to a greater extent than wireless spectrum capacity.
But also to position it mildly it is a massive thin on the American taxpayer. You run across if the spectrum had been auctioned similar traditional spectrum the taxpayer would bring received billions of dollars – dollars that volition mightiness straight off catamenia to Lightsquared together with Falcone. Rarely bring I seen taxpayers laissez passer on away larger gifts to corporates (and that includes the banks) but inward this instance they are giving the gift to 1 slightly compromised billionaire together with his hedge-fund clients. It is actually difficult – nay impossible – to run across whatever policy footing for that gift.
But the FCC (the relevant regulator) rolled over together with granted Falcone permission. McLean points out the political donations involved (they were large my the standards of nigh people, but tiny when billions of dollars are on the line). Falcone also hired the hubby of a fundamental FCC staffer to last a lobbyist. I shouldn't last surprised – this is they way some billionaires brand coin inward the US. But the regulatory nativity of Lightsquared volition cast a stain across its time to come together with its financing – a stain that I hope Falcone can't avoid.
The offset stain is possible interference betwixt Lightsquared's terrestrial network together with GPS. There is non much spectral distance betwixt Lightsquared together with much GPS signal – but GPS signal is weak (it comes from satellites) together with Lightsquared volition last much stronger (it is domestic together with it needs to behave lots of information). That agency that Lightsquared volition potentially interfere alongside GPS networks. Serious people including the defense forcefulness subdivision object to Falcone's purpose of the spectrum. Falcone – quoted inward McLean's articles – accuses the critics of making upward the GPS objection to protect their privileged domestic spectrum positions. Two responses: those critics include the defense forcefulness subdivision together with clearly Falcone is stretching it there, secondly the other critics paid practiced coin to taxpayers for their privileged spectrum seat – Falcone relied on a loophole.]
But the GPS stain is non going away. I don't know whether the spectrum interference is finally or non – but the loophole-political-donation resultant raises makes it to a greater extent than believable. After all this spectrum was non allocated according to criterion international practice.
And the stain is going to arrive actually difficult for Falcone to finance the purpose of this spectrum. After all if the network interferes alongside GPS that volition arrive less useful. After some airplane pilot besides trained to purpose his GPS gets his signal jammed together with crashes a plane Falcone volition uncovering it much harder to keep his ill-gotten spectrum position. Money lent against Lightsquared mightiness last lost because the underlying spectrum ownership is ephemeral.
Carl Icahn it seems has been buying Lightsquared's debt. That volition last a fantastic investment if Lightsquared tin sack larn past times the stain of its birth. But I dubiousness it.
Anyway I hope this post service contributes to the end-failure of Lightsquared. Dirty or incompetent regulators brand bad capitalism. If Falcone had obtained the spectrum the park way, paying the park number of billion dollars together with dealing alongside interference issues (like GPS) inward an opened upward together with transparent way I would bring no problems. As it is Falcone sickens me together with Grassley is correct on the money.
Dear Mr Falcone....
As a director of a modest hedge-fund to 1 of the leaders inward my industry: I volition honor yous in 1 trial to a greater extent than when yous brand your side past times side only direct billion dollars.
It is non this one.
John
If yous don't know the background start alongside Bethany McLean's excellent article on Phil together with Lisa Falcone inward Vanity Fair. I remember McLean tries besides difficult to last balanced on the fundamental policy resultant of spectrum together with Lightsquared - but McLean offers a practiced introduction to the issues. By contrast Grassley is non balanced but he is right. Here is why.
There is an international trunk that administers a binding international treaty on how spectrum should last allocated. That trunk is the International Telecommunications Union.
The rules demand to last binding because otherwise 1 country's communications build-out could jam communications from some other country. This is especially of import where countries are densely packed (like Europe) but is also of import inward the Americas especially regarding satellite spectrum. (After all spectrum purpose past times Argentine Republic could interfere alongside spectrum purpose past times the U.S.A. if that spectrum is used past times a geostationary satellite.)
The biggest conflict is betwixt satellite spectrum together with terrestrial spectrum. Satellites are a long way away (in geosynchronous compass they are 35,786 kilometres inward a higher house the equator). Because they are a long way away the signal is non real powerful together with yous oft demand a dish to grab plenty signal to arrive usable. Being a real weak signal yous demand to ensure that at that spot is no real powerful signal inward the same spectral region. H5N1 powerful signal volition block a weak signal simply every bit sure as shooting every bit a large metropolis radio station tin sack drown out a less powerful regional station a piffling farther upward the (frequency) dial.
The ITU's chore is to brand certain this does non happen. The treaty for instance stops Canadian land-based radio devices jamming distant (and thus much weaker) American satellite devices together with vice-versa.
The offset matter the ITU does it allocates some spectrum every bit global spectrum (mostly for satellites but also for communicating alongside ships at body of body of water together with similar) together with other spectrum every bit terrestrial spectrum which fellow member countries tin sack allocate yet they want. After all at that spot is piffling international resultant inward land-based spectrum because interference is basically local. (A jail cellular telephone phone inward New York does non interfere alongside a jail cellular telephone phone inward London or visa-versa – so the allotment of terrestrial spectrum inward London tin sack last done independently of the American Government or vice-versa.)
Generally satellite spectrum is given away or sold real cheaply – but it comes alongside obligations. The primary obligation is to build out some (normally global) social network (eg communication to remote areas or ships at sea). Terrestrial spectrum is auctioned past times local governments together with oft carries the correct to build a jail cellular telephone phone network. That spectrum is hugely valuable together with is auctioned for billions of dollars.
There is an underlying global policy resultant hither – which is that jail cellular telephone phone purpose is growing similar crazy together with the existent shortages of spectrum are for jail cellular telephone phones rather than for satellites. The iPhone together with other network devices are the heart together with individual culprit together with the inability of many of my readers to purpose their iPhone inward New York City is will to that.
In an ideal globe some of the spectrum allocated to satellites would – over fourth dimension – last shifted to domestic purpose together with auctioned past times the local authorities. This can't last done fast because businesses bring satellites inward infinite at the toll of several billion dollars together with yous can't simply homecoming them useless past times drowning their signal alongside (nearer together with thus much stronger) domestic signal.
Enter Phil Faclone together with Lightsquared. Lightsquared gets access to some satellite spectrum cheaply together with so ploughs headlong into a loophole inward spectrum laws. The loophole is this: satellite spectrum licenses let the structure of ground-based booster stations to retransmit their signal together with thus arrive to a greater extent than useful. The instance envisaged is tell a remote town inward Alaska needs a 6 pes dish to have the signal (and thus tell larn high speed internet). Rather than bring everyone inward the town install a vi pes dish they install a unmarried dish together with so retransmit the signal roughly the town – together with that way everyone inward the remote surface area tin sack purpose the signal cheaply. Seems sensible enough.
But inward the eyes of Falcone this gives him the correct to purpose xl chiliad addition booster stations all they way across America so he tin sack retransmit to everyone. Of course of didactics these booster stations volition also last connected to ground-based fibre networks where appropriate. And so Falcone plans to build some other U.S. national jail cellular telephone phone network or at to the lowest degree to sell spectrum to the existing networks.
This is – to position it mildly – audacious. And at that spot is piffling dubiousness that American consumers would do goodness from to a greater extent than wireless spectrum capacity.
But also to position it mildly it is a massive thin on the American taxpayer. You run across if the spectrum had been auctioned similar traditional spectrum the taxpayer would bring received billions of dollars – dollars that volition mightiness straight off catamenia to Lightsquared together with Falcone. Rarely bring I seen taxpayers laissez passer on away larger gifts to corporates (and that includes the banks) but inward this instance they are giving the gift to 1 slightly compromised billionaire together with his hedge-fund clients. It is actually difficult – nay impossible – to run across whatever policy footing for that gift.
But the FCC (the relevant regulator) rolled over together with granted Falcone permission. McLean points out the political donations involved (they were large my the standards of nigh people, but tiny when billions of dollars are on the line). Falcone also hired the hubby of a fundamental FCC staffer to last a lobbyist. I shouldn't last surprised – this is they way some billionaires brand coin inward the US. But the regulatory nativity of Lightsquared volition cast a stain across its time to come together with its financing – a stain that I hope Falcone can't avoid.
The offset stain is possible interference betwixt Lightsquared's terrestrial network together with GPS. There is non much spectral distance betwixt Lightsquared together with much GPS signal – but GPS signal is weak (it comes from satellites) together with Lightsquared volition last much stronger (it is domestic together with it needs to behave lots of information). That agency that Lightsquared volition potentially interfere alongside GPS networks. Serious people including the defense forcefulness subdivision object to Falcone's purpose of the spectrum. Falcone – quoted inward McLean's articles – accuses the critics of making upward the GPS objection to protect their privileged domestic spectrum positions. Two responses: those critics include the defense forcefulness subdivision together with clearly Falcone is stretching it there, secondly the other critics paid practiced coin to taxpayers for their privileged spectrum seat – Falcone relied on a loophole.]
But the GPS stain is non going away. I don't know whether the spectrum interference is finally or non – but the loophole-political-donation resultant raises makes it to a greater extent than believable. After all this spectrum was non allocated according to criterion international practice.
And the stain is going to arrive actually difficult for Falcone to finance the purpose of this spectrum. After all if the network interferes alongside GPS that volition arrive less useful. After some airplane pilot besides trained to purpose his GPS gets his signal jammed together with crashes a plane Falcone volition uncovering it much harder to keep his ill-gotten spectrum position. Money lent against Lightsquared mightiness last lost because the underlying spectrum ownership is ephemeral.
Carl Icahn it seems has been buying Lightsquared's debt. That volition last a fantastic investment if Lightsquared tin sack larn past times the stain of its birth. But I dubiousness it.
Anyway I hope this post service contributes to the end-failure of Lightsquared. Dirty or incompetent regulators brand bad capitalism. If Falcone had obtained the spectrum the park way, paying the park number of billion dollars together with dealing alongside interference issues (like GPS) inward an opened upward together with transparent way I would bring no problems. As it is Falcone sickens me together with Grassley is correct on the money.
Dear Mr Falcone....
As a director of a modest hedge-fund to 1 of the leaders inward my industry: I volition honor yous in 1 trial to a greater extent than when yous brand your side past times side only direct billion dollars.
It is non this one.
John
No comments